Well, if Ivy and Judy LOVE each other so much, why don't they hold hands?, Kasey asks. As they reluctantly clasp hands, Ivy whispers to Judy that they should just do what they're told so the hazing will be over faster. The sisters joke that maybe the pledges are whispering dirty things to each other. With a laugh, Kasey suggests that she has JUST the thing that will turn these lesbian lovers on EVEN more than whispering to each other. She pulls Ivy's top down, exposing her bra as Ivy gasps in shock. But Ivy shouldn't be the ONLY one without a shirt, so the sisters order Ivy to take Judy's shirt off too. With a deep breath, Ivy begins to remove Judy's top, reassuring her that it'll be over soon. But it's not over yet, and now the sorority sisters want Ivy to take Judy's bra off too. Ivy tells Judy that she's sorry as she unclasps her bra, letting Judy's perky tits pop out. The sisters giggle as poor Judy's eyes fill up with tears. But Ivy's had enough. Yelling that she's sick of this and doesn't need to be treated this way, she storms out. A moment later, Judy hurriedly follows after her.
In an empty bedroom in the sorority house, with the noises of the party fading as they close the door, Ivy and Judy enter and sit on the bed. That was the most skeezy party she's ever been to, Judy adds. What was Judy doing there pledging for the sorority anyway?, Ivy asks. Well, her friend from high school is a sister in that sorority and she invited her to that party to pledge, Judy says. But her friend NEVER told her that she would be treated like that, Judy continues. If she knew that, she never would have come, Judy finishes. Some friend!, Ivy replies. Seriously!, Judy agrees.
There's a moment of silence between the two. Thanks for saving her back there, Judy says softly. It was nothing, all she did was walk away, Ivy says modestly. 'No it wasn't nothing, if you hadn't walked out of there, I wouldn't have had the courage to do the same thing. You're my knight in shining armor,' Judy says, gazing at Ivy with open admiration and moving a little closer to Ivy on the bed. They share a pleasantly tense moment as Ivy looks back at her with a smile.
Ivy breaks eye contact and clears her throat. Anyway, it feels good to get away from those horrible girls, Ivy says. Yeah, totally, Judy agrees. Maybe they should get out of here?, Ivy suggests. Absolutely, Judy agrees. But she doesn't really have any other plans for the night, and to be honest, she was kind of hoping for something ELSE to happen tonight..., Judy says shyly. Oh, what was she hoping would happen?, Ivy asks, sliding a little closer to Judy on the bed. No, she can't tell her, it's way too embarrassing, Judy says. Ivy prompts her, telling her that she won't judge. How does she say this without sounding weird?, Judy asks herself aloud. Ok, she'll just say it, she's a virgin, Judy says quickly. Yeah, she knows, 19 years old and still a virgin, it's pathetic, Judy adds sadly. No it's not, she was 18 when she lost her virginity, it's not pathetic at all, Ivy says kindly. And...even though she didn't appreciate those other girls pressuring her to do it, she...she actually liked it when Ivy touched her back at the party, Judy says sheepishly. Ivy looks at her, biting her lip. And does she like it....now?, Ivy asks and leans in, kissing Judy softly. Judy is nervous, but Ivy tells her to follow her lead as she resumes kissing Judy, this time deeply and passionately, their tongues intertwining.
Ivy takes Judy's bra off, kissing her hard nipples as Judy moans. Ivy slips the rest of Judy's clothes off and buries her face eagerly in Judy's juicy mound. The virginal pledge throws her head back, gasping at the feeling of Ivy's tongue on her clit.
Ivy and Judy have escaped the humiliating hazing ritual, finding solace in each other's arms. And although they might never be SORORITY sisters, before the night is over, they'll get even closer than sorority sisters can EVER be...
They're all getting deep into the story, celebrating having slain an ogre, when Ivy's snobby cheerleader step-sister, Whitney Wright,waltzes in. Immediately, the friends fall into an uncomfortable silence as Whitney plops down at the table with them, announcingthat she's stuck with them for the night. What game is this? One of their dorky pretend games with magic? Whatever, she wants in.
Reluctantly, they let Whitney play, although it isn't long before she's mocking their enthusiasm for the game. When Ivy challengesher step-sister on what she'd have HER character do, Whitney smirks and says she'd have her character put a love spell on Judy'scharacter to make them kiss!
Just like that, Whitney's cast out of the fellowship and the other girls try to get back to playing a proper game. As Ivy continuesnarrating their adventure, Whitney rolls her eyes and slides in behind Judy and Alison, getting up to no good. Whitney starts teasingthem in seductive ways, playing with their hair or caressing their backs. She even goes as far as groping their perky breasts beneaththeir shirts! While Judy and Alison first seem uncomfortable, they soon begin falling under Whitney's spell, much to Ivy's dismay.
Despite Ivy's vehement protests, when Whitney dares Judy and Alison to be as bold as their characters, they're unable to resisttemptation any further. Ivy can do nothing but stare in shock as the other three girls undress before her and starts getting it on. AsWhitney fingers and tongues Judy and Alison's sweet pussies, Ivy does her best to keep her wits about her. However, it isn't longbefore her own resolve finally crumbles -- it looks like the game will just have to wait!
Twenty minutes later, the doorbell rings. Ivy answers it and finds her beautiful wife Riley Reid standing there, dressed as a pizza delivery girl. Ivy invites her in, telling Riley that she seems to have lost her wallet. Is there any OTHER way she can pay?, Ivy asks, sliding her nightgown off her creamy shoulders. Riley politely tells Ivy that she's married. 'So am I,' Ivy says in response, showing Riley her wedding band. She drops the pizza and kisses Ivy. Ivy backs Riley up against a table, squeezing Riley's plump ass as they kiss. Ivy asks Riley to slap her just like Ivy's wife does. Riley grins widely and playfully slaps Ivy's cheek. They lock lips again and as their tongues snake into each other's mouths, Ivy grinds her pussy on Riley, squeezing Riley's little titties. Riley flips Ivy around, pressing those perfect titties against Ivy's back. Ivy's really getting into it now and demands that Riley push her down on the table. Riley doesn't hesitate, bending Ivy over roughly and grabbing a handful of Ivy's juicy ass. Ivy gasps. Riley takes control, sliding Ivy's panties off and tearing off her top quickly. She squeezes her nipples as Ivy screams with pleasure, telling Riley that that is just how her wife does it, only better.
Ivy decides it's time to move the action to her bedroom and leads Riley up the stairs. But they can't get enough of each other and only make it to the landing at the top of the stairs before they start hungrily kissing each other again. Ivy rips Riley's shirt off, getting a mouthful of her perky tits. As Riley traces her lips down Ivy's stomach, Ivy tells her that her wife ate her pussy in that very spot just the other day. Riley smiles, tonguing Ivy's clit. Ivy squeals in delight as her wife's tongue glides up and down her clit softly. Ivy slips Riley's jean shorts off and leans her against the railing, spreading her perfect legs as she eats her pussy. Pretty soon both girls are wet and ready and they finally move the party to Ivy's bedroom, where things are about to get even wilder. Even though she's not really a pizza delivery girl, Riley is more than happy to play that role and give Ivy a special delivery that she won't soon forget.